Excellent review R!
There has been some previous discussion on Basenotes as to what the "S" note really is......I'll leave it up to your imagination as to what some people think.... :-O
I'd be curious to read your take on a comparison of Mugler's Cologne and Creed's Original Vetiver. To me, they are amazingly similar with Cologne pre-dating OV. OV seems to add some depth and it's a bit greener but I think they are too close for comfort.
Regards, Eric

E,

Too bad the old posts on basenotes aren't accessible, but I can imagine ;-)

I had actually decided that the "S" note was probably a little dollop of Guerlain Vetiver, but now that you mention the Creed, which is much fresher and blander, I will have to try them together.

The infamous S note named S.S is actually a sap note, so minds out of the gutter! LOL Everything about this scent works...the bottle, the color of the juice and the scent. If I were a guy, this would be in my fragrance stable, but I only spritz it on myself when passing by the fragrance counter!

P, Darn, I was enjoying the gutter ;-)

I find it very unisex, but I only see it in the men's departments, so I guess you are not alone in finding it too masculine.

I read once that the "S" was from a 14th Century formula. Extrapolating that they liked musk and ambergris then, perhaps the earthy note is a version of them (synthetic, of course, nowadays.) Also read once that there is bamboo (leaf, wood?) in there. If it is vetiver, is is a masterful use of it, because I am no a fan of it, and don't detect it.

Funny you didn't think you'd be drawn to it, but were, R. I wanted to like it, and it never lasted on me. Then a friend on the West Coast said hers lasted for hours. Well, I had to wait for winter to experience the lovely drydown and hours-long enjoyment. I live in Miami, and Cologne just -whooshes - off my skin in our typical heat and humidity, even indoors in 80-degree air-conditioning!

Now it is my favorite commercial winter scent. Then it lasts like an eau de parfum would ;-)

Anya, I have heard bamboo too, but it doesn't smell like bamboo to me. Your nose, I am sure, is way better than mine, so will accept that there is no vetiver, but whatever is in the base smells very much like Guerlain Vetiver to me.

It lasts at least 8 hours on me, maybe longer.

I am still surprised that I like it. I don't usually like soapy, and other really clean fragrances, like Gendarme, leave me cold.

This scent that everyone calls "bamboo" just doesn't smell like bamboo to me either, so maybe it is "bamboo", whatever that is. I would be surprised if there's no vetiver in it, though.

I swapped for many little bottles of this one, and I am very fond of it. No, it's not your run-of-the-mill "shower fresh" scent by any stretch. I certainly smell some earthy-herbal vetiver going on in there. In fact, I think my taste for vetiver may date from when I tried this! (On the other hand, I find Creed Original Vetiver--confusingly, not their first vetiver scent but their most recent--to be a screaming bore.)

Ok, glad I am not the only one who is smelling something vetiver-ish.

I was surprised by Vetiver Original. I guess they figure it will appeal to a more modern, unisex audience. I prefer the Guerlain.

You and NST are making me curious about this. Of course, I love the color of the ad ;D.
Blue Gert

R, there may well be vetiver in there. I have a real aversion to it, yet have found many scents I love include it -- go figger. I dilute it way, way down for my blends, and it disappears, yet provides a structure for the base. Same with Ylang ylang -- despise the EO, yet use it in blends. All this epiphany came about after discovering that many of my favorite commercial perfumes contained it, and I was being prejudiced by the "straight" stuff. Today is absolutely too hot to sniff or wear 'fumes, so I'll wait until nightfall and resample the Cologne, looking avidly for vetiver sneaking around in there ;-)

I still have a sneaking suspicion the lovely, light base notes (oxymoron, eh?) in Cologne are from a musk/ambergris type of accord. Tiny bit of fecal oomph under the singing high notes, a milky, fat bottom roundness that doesn't hint of the darkness of vetiver.

A, Well let me know what you find! Agree there is no darkness. Also saw the bit about the 14th century manuscripts on osmoz, but I guess I didn't take it very seriously. We'll have to get a sample of that Moroccan soap!

Excuse me for not knowing it anyone can help, but who are the Reviewers for the perfume website that are shown each day?

Hi Thelma, I am the reviewer. My name is Robin, and you can read more under the "About" link on the navigation bar at the top of the page.

OK, I went to my perfume cabinet (yeah, that much) and pulled it out. Like I said, I rarely wear perfumes in the summer here. God, this is a pretty, beautiful scent. I've never smelled it on a man, although it's supposed to be unisex.

The gorgeous lush sweet opening tops of citrus are just fun and playful like a pretty flute heard off in the distance, drawing you in -- completely irresistable. Lots of sweet lemon and citron and maybe distilled lime. If I had to say there was a hint of cucumber inthere, I would say it's from violet leaf or synthetic. There is neroli and maybe even orange flower absolute to extend it, something more petal than rind, IMO

This definitely uses, and brilliantly, the dreaded ylang. There is a grassy wood there, which is what I suppose they mean by bamboo. Then, in the bottom I detect woods like cedar and sandalwood (maybe synthetic) and some iron-free patchouli.

No vetiver, still, to me.

Now here's the fun part. I take off the cap and first inhale in the left nostril, then the right. The olfactory receptors are directly wired to the corresponding part of the brain, not switched. The left allows you to logically dissect a scent. There is that animalic tone, oh sweet jessus on a Segway. Yum!

The right nostril, wired to emotions and memories, takes me to citrus groves, lemonade, sweet flowers and good clean sex ;-)
More yum.

Ah, maybe it's that grassy wood bamboo thing plus patchouli that smells like vetiver to me. So the S note is a Sex note? Fun!

A, will say it again -- your nose is way better than mine! No way do I smell all that.

R, I smell even more, but I don't know what it is! I suspect the sandalwood is synthetic, or Australian. The cedar is distinct, especially with the patchouli marriage.

If you ever track down that Moroccan soap, put me in for a case. Morocco! That's a clue. Back to musing on this scent, with Moroccan angle.

Well before you go off on a wild goose chase...he found the soap in a Moroccan hotel, but I don't know that it was "native"...could be from anywhere!

This is nice stuff, but when I tested it on my skin I found it sits almost too neatly between three other scents I really love: AdP Colonia Intensia, Romeo Gigli Man and Nicole Farhi PH. The latter is the most spicy of the trio and is my favourite; it also lasts well for such a transluscent scent. The Gigli is also warm and spicy, but with a greener hue, while the AdP is warmer still and a bit darker, without ever becoming opaque. If you've got any one of that trio in your wardbrobe, then it obviates the need for the Mugler Cologne. If you haven't tried any of them, I'd highly recommend the Farhi and the Gigli.

I like the TM much better than the AdP, but haven't tried the other 2, and as TM is much easier to get ahold of here, I might as well stick with it :-)

Yay Cologne...to make up for the Angel horror. Goes on stong citrusy (lemony) that lasts for a good while. Tames down nicely. Get quite a bit of compliments on this one.

It's great stuff!